Why two BJP MLA’s ,Shagun Parihar and Sunil Sharma corner senior police officers over killing of two SPOs in Kishtwar; demand high-level probe

Kumaonadmin
13 Min Read

Ashvini Kumar

Questions over alleged operational lapses, missing weapons, three-day delay in recovery of bodies and manner in which mortal remains were transported put police under pressure

The killing of two Special Police Officers (SPOs) in the mountainous Kuntwara area of Kishtwar has triggered widespread outrage, with BJP MLA from Kishtwar Shagun Parihar and Leader of Opposition (LoP) in the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly Sunil Sharma confronting senior police officers on spot and demanding accountability for what they described as serious lapses in the handling of the operation and the recovery of the bodies.

In an emotionally charged confrontation, the two BJP legislators questioned senior police officers, including DIG Doda-Kishtwar Range Sargun Shukla, over the circumstances surrounding the deaths and the manner in which the mortal remains of the two personnel were brought back.

The anger was not limited to the loss of two lives. It centred on the dignity allegedly denied to the deceased personnel, the suffering of their families and the unanswered questions surrounding the operation.

Shagun Parihar reportedly questioned the officers as to why the bodies of the two deceased SPOs were brought in a tipper/dumper after three days and why, according to the allegations raised during the confrontation, even proper arrangements such as covering the bodies with shrouds had not been ensured.

“Is this how we honour those who sacrificed their lives for the country?” was the central sentiment expressed during the heated exchange.

The grieving families and fellow personnel were particularly distressed by the alleged manner in which the bodies were transported. The emotional reference to a young daughter who would have to watch footage of her father’s mortal remains being carried in a dumper brought the human tragedy into sharp focus.

For the families, the issue is not merely about the loss of their loved ones; it is also about whether the State machinery showed the respect and dignity that personnel serving in dangerous conditions deserve.

Sunil Sharma, who represents Padder-Nagseni in the Assembly, launched a sharp attack on the police leadership, questioning the operational strategy that allegedly left the two SPOs exposed in a remote and vulnerable forest area.

He reportedly asked senior officers what kind of operational planning required two local police personnel to travel through a dense forest to assist an Army post, apparently without adequate security arrangements.

Sharma also questioned the weapons provided to the two personnel, reportedly one .303 rifle and one INSAS rifle, asking whether this was an appropriate arrangement for personnel being deployed in a sensitive operational area.

“We have also seen several operations, but I have never witnessed such incompetence,” was the substance of his angry remarks.

He sought accountability from the officers responsible for preparing the duty roster and deploying the two SPOs outside the territorial jurisdiction of their normal place of posting.

According to local accounts reported in the media, the two personnel had concerns about repeated deployment at a Temporary Operational Base (TOB) in Dharna village, Marwah. Their families and villagers have also raised questions about the weekly rotation arrangement.

The deaths have raised a series of serious questions that the police investigation must address. These are questions requiring evidence-based answers, not speculation.

What exactly happened? Were the two SPOs ambushed by terrorists while travelling through the forest, or were they abducted and subsequently killed?

Where are their service weapons? Both service weapons were reportedly missing when the bodies were recovered. Were the rifles taken away by the attackers? If so, what does the forensic evidence indicate?

Was there an exchange of fire? Were spent cartridges or other ballistic evidence recovered from the scene? Did the forensic team establish whether the SPOs fired their weapons in self-defence?

What do the post-mortem reports reveal? How many bullet injuries did each personnel sustain? Where were the injuries located — the head, neck, chest or other parts of the body? What does the medical evidence indicate about the sequence of events?

Who was responsible? Has any terrorist organisation claimed responsibility? Have investigators identified suspected attackers or established a possible terrorist connection?

Was there an intelligence or operational failure? Why were the two personnel travelling through a vulnerable forest stretch without adequate protection? Was their movement known to suspected militants?

Was the deployment justified? Who prepared the duty roster, who authorised the deployment and whether the concerns reportedly expressed by the personnel were taken into consideration?

Why was there a delay in communicating with the families and local residents? Why did senior officers take time to reach the village, and why was the transportation of the mortal remains handled in the manner alleged by the families?

These questions assume particular significance because the missing service weapons could provide an important investigative lead. However, their disappearance alone does not establish the identity of the killers or prove which organisation was responsible.

The anger of the two BJP legislators appears to have been driven by three interconnected issues.

The alleged security failure: Two local SPOs were killed while travelling through a difficult mountainous area. The legislators want to know whether adequate precautions were taken.

The alleged indignity to the deceased: The families and local residents were deeply hurt by the reported transportation of the bodies in a dumper without proper coffins or arrangements.

The perceived lack of administrative accountability: The delayed arrival of senior officers and the absence of a detailed public explanation intensified the anger.

Shagun Parihar’s confrontation with DIG Sargun Shukla was particularly emotional. She questioned why senior officers had not visited the families earlier and why the administration had failed to ensure dignity for the deceased.

The most painful part of the confrontation was her reference to the young daughter who had lost her father.

The protest was not simply an exchange between politicians and police officers. It reflected the grief of families who had lost their breadwinners and the anger of a remote community that feels its security concerns have not received adequate attention.

Why are BJP legislators questioning the police when the security establishment is under the Lieutenant Governor and Union Government?

This is perhaps the most important political question arising from the incident. Jammu and Kashmir is a Union Territory where the police and public order fall within the administrative domain of the Lieutenant Governor, rather than the elected government’s ordinary portfolio.

Under the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act and subsequent business rules, the Lieutenant Governor has a significant role in matters relating to police, public order and All India Services. The Union Ministry of Home Affairs also exercises the Centre’s jurisdiction over J&K’s security administration.

Therefore, the BJP legislators’ criticism of senior police officers raises a larger question of political accountability.

Why are BJP legislators publicly confronting police officers appointed under the existing administrative system?

Are they expressing genuine anger over alleged operational failures, or is the confrontation also intended to put pressure on the police leadership?

If the police administration is answerable to the Lieutenant Governor and the Union Government, should the responsibility not extend to the highest levels of the security establishment?

Will the Union Home Ministry seek an explanation from the police leadership?

The BJP legislators are entitled to question the police as elected representatives, irrespective of which party controls the administrative machinery. Their criticism should not automatically be interpreted as a political dispute.

However, it also makes the issue politically significant because the BJP is in power at the Centre, and the Union Home Ministry has an important role in J&K’s security administration.

A difficult question for the administration: Is terrorism really on its last leg?

Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha has repeatedly projected the security situation in Jammu and Kashmir as having improved significantly, with terrorism nearing its end.

However, the killing of two SPOs in Kishtwar, coming amid other security incidents in the region, raises questions about the security arrangements in remote and mountainous areas.

The incident is particularly concerning because Kishtwar’s upper reaches have historically witnessed militant activity.

If terrorism is indeed on its last leg, the administration must explain how two local police personnel could be killed in such circumstances and why their service weapons went missing.

The families and residents of Kiyar, Dachhan and surrounding villages deserve clear answers, not merely assurances.

The two men were cremated in their native Kiyar village on Friday. On Saturday, senior police officers, including IGP Jammu Tejinder Singh and DIG Sargun Shukla, visited the area and met the families.

The deaths of Rashpal Kumar and Bobby Chand deserve a thorough and impartial investigation.

A high-level inquiry should examine:

  • The circumstances in which the two SPOs were deployed.
  • The duty roster and the officers who authorised their movement.
  • Whether they had previously raised concerns about their deployment.
  • The missing service weapons and ammunition.
  • Forensic and ballistic evidence from the crime scene.
  • Post-mortem findings and the sequence of injuries.
  • Possible intelligence failure or leakage of their movement.
  • The arrangements made for recovering and transporting their bodies.
  • The conduct and response of officers following the incident.
  • The inquiry should also establish whether the deaths resulted from an ambush, abduction or another form of attack. No conclusion about the perpetrators or their organisation should be drawn without evidence.
  • Behind this controversy are two families who have lost their loved ones.
  • One father will never return home. A daughter will grow up without her father’s protection. Another family has lost a member who served in a difficult and sensitive mountainous region.
  • SPOs are often local residents who assist the police in areas where difficult terrain, poor connectivity and security threats make ordinary policing extremely challenging.
  • They serve alongside regular police personnel and other security forces, often at considerable personal risk.
  • Their lives cannot be treated as expendable simply because they hold the rank of SPO.
  • The question is not merely who killed Rashpal Kumar and Bobby Chand. The question is also whether everything possible was done to protect them while they were performing their duty.
  • Their families deserve justice, their sacrifice deserves dignity, and the people of Kishtwar deserve answers.
  • People of Kishtwar are raising and asking questions, why Lt Governor , Manoj Sinha not announcing High level probe into the killings of two SPOs ? Is someone defending any agency ?
Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *